Name: Tomatoes Pizzeria
Price range: $$

Tomatoes Pizzeria Information

Stepping into Tomatoes Pizzeria at 701 Lacey Rd, Forked River, NJ, you’re immediately greeted by the comforting aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce, setting the tone for a genuinely cozy dining experience. The menu here is a celebration of classic Italian-American favorites, from generously topped pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts to hearty calzones that ooze with cheese and savory fillings. Regulars rave about the balance of flavors in their signature Margherita and pepperoni pies, noting that the sauce has just the right tang to complement the fresh mozzarella without overpowering the toppings. Beyond pizza, the menu offers an array of pastas and sandwiches, each prepared with attention to detail and portion sizes that feel satisfying without being overwhelming. The atmosphere at Tomatoes Pizzeria is casual and inviting, with a friendly staff that makes both dine-in and takeout feel effortless, often remembering familiar faces and preferences, which adds a personal touch to the visit. The interior is clean and unpretentious, with simple seating that encourages relaxed meals, while the buzz of the kitchen adds an energetic backdrop to the experience. Many diners appreciate that despite the popularity of the place, service tends to be swift, and orders are consistently accurate, whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a family dinner. Parking is straightforward, and the location along Lacey Rd makes it an easy stop for locals and travelers alike looking for a dependable, flavor-packed meal. Reviewers often highlight the consistency in quality over time, noting that every visit delivers that satisfying combination of fresh ingredients, well-executed recipes, and a warm, welcoming vibe that makes it more than just a meal-it’s a little slice of Forked River comfort. Whether you’re a fan of classic thin-crust pizza, loaded specialty pies, or just in the mood for a reliable Italian-American bite, Tomatoes Pizzeria offers a menu and experience that keeps both casual diners and pizza enthusiasts coming back.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Love this pizzeria in FR! My family and I always order takeout, and the delivery is fast. They always follow delivery instructions perfectly, leaving the food at the door without knocking or ringing the bell, which is great since my children and dogs are sleeping. They have delicious specialty slices, great sides, tasty desserts, and kid-friendly meals. Thank you to the team for consistently great service—highly recommend!

It was amazing. The staff is the most friendliest staff I have ever met. Fernando is the best. The food is amazing and the staff is amazing the atmosphere is amazing and don't even get me started on the prices. 100,000/100,000

So my car broke down on Lacey Road. I am having to get into the PNC Bank across the street from this place. I walked across the street with my friend to see if any of the delivery drivers or anybody that was there would be able to help me if they had jumper cables out of everybody there happening to be all men there was one single female working. The female only female working happened to be the only one with jumper, cables, and able to help me. This girl is a lifesaver not only did she help me. She got her jumper, cables, singed thank goodness she had another pair and my car still not not work and she stayed with us to make sure that we could start try to get help afterwards. I had to wait for a tow truck because My card never turned back on. We decided to get a slice of pizza and a drink while we were there waiting. Pizza was so good and I got a sausage peppers and onion slice it was not too cooked not undercooked could just right and the taste was great as well. I will only be recommending this pizza place for Lacey because not only do they have good food. They have some good staff members. PS. She needs a race. Thanks again.

Let's talk about their Strombolis, absolutely perfect and what really brings it to another level is their Tomatoe sauce. Look at the picture you can feed a family for a week with that bad boy. 2 I usually get my food delivered from Tomatoes. But I was going home and decided to stop on in. I just ordered a large pie with pepperoni. When I got home, it was like it was right out of the oven. Their food is the best around but man that pie last night was the best! 3 Their food is definitely made with love. They have the best Pepperoni Pizza in Lacey, hands down. Shout out to my delivery guy, Ray.

We ordered online and got a spinach pizza. It was $18.23 for this pizza. The other part of our order had a pizza with onions, green peppers, sausage, and meatball for $26.73. I think that this is a little pricey for what it is, but I’m glad to support a local pizzeria that I have been visiting for years now. I have never gotten the spinach pie before, but I kind of regretted it because there was a LOT of spinach on the pie. Typically, when I order a pie with spinach, there’s maybe 50% less spinach on it. But, it was still decent, I just wish I had gotten it plain because it was a little overwhelming. I recommend getting the grandma because that’s a classic.

We have been ordering form here since we moved to FR we’ve always had a good experience. My only complaint is that tonight my pizza was delivered as seen in the picture. Not sure how this happens in a mile drive so rather disappointed. Overall we like this place, perhaps I’ll go back to picking up

Personally I don't like their pizza, but my family really likes it. For me, there is too much garlic, but the flavor is there itself is very good. Also their grandma pie is too high rising, but again my family loves it. The staff is really nice though you can tell they do care about their cooking and they do want you to enjoy their business. A lady came in to pick up a catering order while I was waiting on my pies and I got the impression they want their customers to be well fed and felt taken care of. That gives the 5 star for me, despite my preference elsewhere.

Our go-to place every Sunday for takeout. Excellent food and service!! Super quick delivery

Tomatoes Pizzeria